Speeches by Opher.

“Q Liz, you spoke about excellent palliative care. What were the reasons, do you think, that your brother wanted to end his life? It did not sound as though he was particularly depressed. Liz Reed: No, he absolutely was not depressed.”

“Certainly.”

“May I ask a further question, Mrs Harris?”

“Q I would just like to ask Claire about medication—not specifically the drugs and everything, but clause 18, “Provision of assistance”. We have heard that in Australia the medication is left with the patient, whereas under this legislation the co-ordinating doctor brings the medication to the house or the place where t…”

“Q Another hon. Member has asked my question, but I have another. We heard yesterday about domestic violence and elder abuse. Does the legislation need to be tightened around that type of area—the coercion of older people into taking their lives early, potentially for financial benefit? Dr Ward: That picks up on the pre…”

“It was clause 26, sorry. Professor Hoyano: Under the Canadian system, the provinces each have a college of physicians and surgeons. However, what has happened is that everyone has worked collaboratively across all 12 jurisdictions, plus the federal Government. We now have the Canadian MAiD—medical assistance in dying—c…”

“Now you’re asking. Let me check. Dr Ward: In the interests of time, let me say that I moved to Queensland a year and a half ago, as I mentioned at the beginning, and took up an academic fellowship at the Australian Centre for Health Law Research. That university was tasked by the Government states of Victoria, Western …”

“Q My question is directed to Amanda and Laura. There is a lot of natural concern about coercion with the Bill. We recognise that it is a difficult thing to assess. Would either of you change the wording of the Bill to make coercion less likely? Dr Ward: Which clause are we looking at?”

“Q Just to confirm—you have not had any failures of treatment, as far as you are aware? Dr Furst: There have been no failures of treatment in South Australia, as far as I am aware. I am not aware of any other particular ones around the country that have been heavily broadcast to us.”

“Q265 I would like to direct this question to Dr Furst. There has been some concern in this country about the efficacy of end-of-life medications. Could you share some of your experience in Australia about how effective they are and any problems you have encountered? Dr Furst: The medications are completely effective. I…”

“Q I was interested to hear what you were saying about not all symptoms being controllable with palliative care. There is an argument that we do not have good enough palliative care, so we cannot bring in assisted dying. I think it may be a little spurious. What are your thoughts about the relationship between palliativ…”

“Q It seems clear from an expert in European law that the human rights convention is covered by this legislation, so we have got some very good advice there. I would just like to confirm that, if we could, Dr Graham. Also, to all of you: could we have some positive things that we could put in the Bill to make it safer? …”

“And do they—”

“Q First, I work as a GP with old people—I look after a nursing home— and I have to do adult safeguarding training every year. Secondly, more than 90% of psychological assessments are done in primary care. Professor Esmail, do you think that GPs are capable of spotting coercion and doing a psychological assessment? Prof…”

“Actually, my question has already been asked. Chelsea Roff: May I respond briefly? I want to address the question. I know it is not your intention for eating disorders to be included in this Bill, and I am grateful for that. When I started our research, I thought, “We just need stronger safeguards.” That was where I be…”

“Can I just confirm—”

“Q Could you briefly run through the patient pathway? Where does the patient first arrive in the healthcare setting? Who are the two doctors? Indeed, who provides assistance at the end of life? Dr McLaren: Again, each of our states, as well as the Australian Capital Territory, has different legislation and therefore dif…”

“Q I am interested in the opt-out whereby ethically, doctors can opt out of taking the decision for patients. Would they then need to steer someone towards another doctor, or can they just simply refuse to do it? Professor Whitty: Duncan may wish to comment for nurses. For doctors, we should be very mindful of the fact …”

“Q Sir Nicholas, I have great sympathy with your position, but how would you frame this law so that it would cover yourself? Sir Nicholas Mostyn: I would frame the law to define terminal illness in the way that it is defined here in clause 2(1)(a), but where the “person’s death in consequence” is referred to, I would de…”

“Q I have a couple of points to make. First, clause 4(5) states that a “registered medical practitioner who is unwilling” to go forward with the assisted dying request “must, if requested…refer…to another registered medical practitioner”. Are you happy with that clause? Dr Green: No, we are not, because we know from our…”