Finance (No. 2) Bill Report Stage: Amendment 5

**What happened**: On 11 March 2026, MPs voted on Amendment 5 to the Finance (No. 2) Bill at Report Stage -- the legislative phase where the full House of Commons considers proposed changes to a bill after it has been through detailed committee scrutiny. The amendment, put forward from the right of the political spectrum as a challenge to the government's budget proposals, was defeated by 283 votes to 172. The government successfully defended its original fiscal legislation. **Why it matters**: The Finance (No. 2) Bill is the legal vehicle through which the government enacts the tax and spending measures announced in the Budget. Amendment 5 sought to modify those measures, though the limited debate extracts available do not allow precise identification of the specific provision targeted. The bill's passage matters practically to taxpayers and businesses: media coverage around this period focused heavily on increases to Air Passenger Duty taking effect from April 2026, suggesting tax rises affecting travellers were among the live policy changes embedded in the legislation. Defeating the amendment keeps the government's original fiscal plans on course. **The politics**: The vote split almost entirely along government-versus-opposition lines. Labour and Labour Co-operative MPs voted unanimously against the amendment (283 Noes), while Conservatives (96), Liberal Democrats (52), Reform UK (7), the Greens (4), Plaid Cymru (4), and several smaller parties and independents all voted in favour. This broad but ultimately outnumbered cross-opposition alliance reflects the standard dynamic of a majority government holding its budget legislation intact. The vote sits within a wider pattern of fiscal confrontation: in late March 2026, the government also successfully defeated multiple Lords amendments to the National Insurance Contributions (Employer Pensions Contributions) Bill, consistently winning those divisions by margins of around 115 votes -- suggesting a government confident in its parliamentary majority on economic matters.