Committee publication · Report · 6 June 2025 · HC 727

7th Report - Industrial Strategy

From: Business and Trade Committee

Inquiry: Industrial Strategy

Government response deadline: 6 August 2025

Summary

This seventh report from the Business and Trade Committee scrutinises the Government's proposed modern industrial strategy, published as a Green Paper in October 2024. The Committee welcomes the strategy as essential to achieving G7-leading growth but identifies critical gaps: unclear vision, insufficient metrics, weak governance structures, and barriers in public procurement, energy costs, skills, and access to finance. The report establishes ten tests to hold the Government accountable throughout the Parliament for delivering a coherent, stable industrial policy.

Key findings

  • The UK's history of industrial policy inconsistency has damaged economic performance; businesses investing over 15–20 year horizons require policy stability to justify long-term capital commitments.
  • Eight growth-driving sectors identified (advanced manufacturing, clean energy, creative, defence, digital/tech, financial services, life sciences, professional services) but the industrial strategy lacks clear mechanisms to balance growth targets against net zero, regional development, and economic security objectives.
  • Broken systems in public procurement, high energy prices, skills shortages, innovation diffusion problems, and finance access are holding back growth; these foundational barriers must be addressed alongside sector-specific support.
  • The Government has not yet explained the precise contribution the industrial strategy will make to the Growth Mission target of fastest G7 growth by end of Parliament; IMF forecasts still show UK growth lagging US and Canada.
  • Japan's mission-oriented approach (since 2021) offers lessons: linking grand challenges to sectors, using public-private partnerships, and providing multi-year financial commitments to attract private investment in batteries, semiconductors, and biopharmaceuticals.

Recommendations

  • Set out a clear vision for the industrial strategy including ambition to decarbonise a fairer and faster-growing economy by transforming the '4i's': raising investment rates, accelerating innovation diffusion, creating inclusive growth, and immunising against geo-political shock.
  • Establish clear metrics to judge progress in closing the growth gap and track not only headline growth but diffusion of innovation through supply chains, decarbonisation progress, and regional distribution of jobs.
  • Define grand challenges or clear goals to galvanise whole-of-government effort and private-sector collaboration across sectors beyond the eight growth-driving priorities.
  • Set clear targets for using trade deals and export teams to deliver growing market share in priority sectors.
  • Transform public procurement organisation to drive UK growth, reduce non-tariff barriers, and create 'behind the border' opportunities for UK exporters in growth-driving sectors.
  • Level the playing field on industrial energy prices with international competitors through policy changes.
  • Devolve responsibility for post-16 technical education and training to local leaders (where adequate), transfer skills responsibility to Department for Business and Trade.
  • Expand the Regulatory Innovation Office to act as clearing house for conflicting regulations and provide businesses a reporting mechanism.
  • Introduce legislation to put the Industrial Strategy Council on a statutory footing.
  • Through the Spending Review, appropriately fund the strategy and clarify the sum of public expenditure allocated to it and the Growth Mission for the remainder of Parliament.
  • Clarify how the Government plans to balance tensions between maximising headline growth, supporting existing industrial jobs, and achieving net zero, economic security, and regional growth objectives.
  • Continue scrutiny of forthcoming Defence Industrial Strategy, steel strategy delivery, and British Steel management through the Steel Industry (Special Measures) Act 2025.

Tone

Critical

Topics

industrial-strategyeconomic-growthpublic-procurementenergy-policyskills-training

Key actors

Liam Byrne, Department for Business and Trade, Industrial Strategy Advisory Council, Tata Steel, British Steel, Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (Japan), International Monetary Fund, Institute for Government

Notable line

… the price of further inconsistency is high; Government must prioritise giving businesses and investors the stability and certainty they need.

Key Quotes

… when policies chop and change this leads to uncertainty that in turn increases the risk for business.
Professor Diane Coyle · explaining why policy consistency matters for investment decisions
We can have an industrial strategy by default or design.
Sir Vince Cable · distinguishing deliberate industrial strategy from unplanned government influence on the economy
To me, getting that potential growth rate up is the real target, because that is what drives living standards and the quality of life for people in this country, over not just the next two years but the next five and 10 years.
Professor Diane Coyle · on the importance of long-term productivity growth over short-term forecasting
A broken system of public procurement, high energy prices, skills shortages, problems with the diffusion of innovation, troubles accessing finance, coupled with the sheer complexity of key institutions, are holding back growth, deterring investment and hampering the spread of cutting-edge business practice.
Business and Trade Committee · summarising systemic barriers to growth that the industrial strategy must address
Government must remain agile and responsive in such a complex global environment, the price of further inconsistency is high …
Business and Trade Committee · concluding remarks on balancing flexibility with the need for stable, long-term industrial policy
View original document →

Source · parliament.uk record ↗

7th Report - Industrial Strategy | Beyond The Vote | Beyond The Vote